Skip to main content
← Back to Blog
Labor Unions

How Union Election Buyers Can Evaluate a Voting-System Audit

By Votem Compliance Team·November 19, 2026

A voting-system audit can help a union election committee assess a provider, but an audit label alone does not explain what was examined, whether the findings apply to the system being offered, or how candidates can observe the election. Ask for the underlying scope and a practical explanation before you choose a provider.



This guide is for committees buying remote electronic voting services for union officer elections covered by Title IV of the Labor-Management Reporting and Disclosure Act (LMRDA). Coverage depends on the union and election. Check your governing documents and obtain advice for your circumstances.



Start with observer rights, not a certificate



Labor-Management Reporting and Disclosure Act, section 401 requires adequate safeguards for a fair election, including a candidate's right to an observer at the polls and at the counting of ballots. In Electing Union Officers Using Remote Electronic Voting Systems, the Department of Labor's Office of Labor-Management Standards (OLMS) recognizes that remote systems cannot always be observed in the same way as a physical count.



OLMS describes possible ways to provide meaningful indirect observation, including open-source code inspection at the observer's cost, reliance on a system auditor, or another meaningful opportunity to confirm that votes are recorded as cast and counted accurately. Its guidance also expects an opportunity to observe parts of the process that are traditionally observable. The agency assesses complaints case by case; its examples are not a safe harbor, and it does not endorse a particular auditor. An audit should therefore be considered as part of an observation plan, not as a reason to dispense with that plan.



Ask what the audit actually covers



Before comparing proposals, request a written explanation of the audit's scope, date, methods, limitations and findings. The following are practical procurement questions, not a list of separate OLMS mandates:




  • Which system was examined? Identify the product, components and software version or configuration covered. Ask how those match the service proposed for your election, including any telephone or other channel in scope.

  • What was tested? Ask whether the work examined vote recording, tallying, credential handling, access controls or other specific processes. A general security review may have a different scope from an examination of how votes are recorded and counted.

  • Who performed it? Ask about the auditor's qualifications, relationship to the provider, and whether the auditor can explain the work and its limits to the committee or observers.

  • What was outside scope? Request the exclusions, the dates of the work and any material changes since then. Ask which findings remain open, what has been corrected, and whether corrective work was independently retested.

  • What evidence is available? Establish what the committee and candidate observers can review, when they can review it, and who answers technical questions. Resolve access or confidentiality issues before signing rather than assuming a marketing summary will be enough.



When comparing answers, separate a description of a system at the time it was examined from proof about your election's actual setup and operation. If the provider cannot connect the audit scope to the proposed service, record the gap and ask how it will be resolved.



Connect the audit to an observer plan



Identify the election steps observers can directly watch and the evidence they will receive for less visible electronic steps. OLMS identifies opportunities to observe eligibility-list review and credential preparation and distribution. Its guidance says observers must be able to watch the credential process without seeing the specific credentials sent to individual members. The Fact Sheet: Observer Rights and Responsibilities in Elections of Union Officers explains observer rights and responsibilities, including observation of eligibility verification and ballot counting.



Ask the provider to demonstrate a practice election with synthetic voters and ballots. Agree on expected results before the demonstration; let observers see the test and how the practice tally is produced. Document questions, discrepancies and their resolution. OLMS lists a witnessed practice-ballot test as a favorable safeguard; a successful demonstration does not by itself establish compliance or prove what happened in the live election.



For example, a hypothetical union committee could compare an audit's stated scope with its planned ballot configuration, then invite candidate observers to a practice tally and explain how they may observe credential distribution and the live count. No real voter information is needed for the practice exercise. The committee would still need to assess its full election process and applicable rules.



Protect secrecy while preserving useful evidence



Ask how the provider prevents an observer review, support record or audit handoff from exposing an individual member's voting credentials or linking a voter to a ballot choice. Do not assume that removing a name from a file automatically prevents identification. Agree who can access sensitive records and how questions will be handled without sharing secret credentials or ballot choices.



For covered secret-ballot officer elections, section 401(e) requires the designated election officials, or the secretary if no other official is designated, to preserve ballots and other election records for one year. OLMS's remote-voting guidance lists records including eligibility lists, voting credentials, log files, time-stamped software code, protected encrypted ballot files and tally results. Confirm who will preserve the records, how the union can access them, and whether a longer hold is needed in the circumstances. Preserve sensitive records securely rather than placing them in an unrestricted observer packet.



Put the answers in the procurement record



Keep a short decision record identifying the audit reviewed, its scope and date, unresolved questions, the planned observer opportunities, and the person responsible for each follow-up. If evidence is unavailable, ask for a specific alternative and assess it before deciding whether to proceed. Apply the same questions to each proposal.



For related planning, see Votem's union officer election guide. If you are preparing an election, you can also ask Votem about your voting and observer-planning needs.



This article provides general election-administration information, not legal advice. Consult the linked primary sources and qualified advisers about your election.


Ready to Run a Compliant Election?

Book a 15-minute call with our election compliance team.

Book a 15-Min Review

Ready to modernize your next election?